BRONTE PROJECT//Agnes Grey- Anne Bronte


Poor Anne. Not even rated by her sister (Charlotte presented her as a bit of a wet lettuce in her introduction to the re-issue of her sisters’ novels; Agnes Grey didn’t even get a mention), she’s been relegated to being the forgotten sister. Her novels don’t have the astonishing power of Wuthering Heights, or the gutsiness of Jane Eyre, but they do have a special pull all of their own.


Of all the sisters, I think you ‘see’ more of Anne as she was in her everyday life in her writing. The only one of the Bronte children to successfully hold down a long-term job, this is demonstrated through the realism of her work. Agnes Grey tells the story of a long-suffering governess and bears remarkable similarities to what we know about Anne’s own work as a governess. She may have gone down in history as the quietest Bronte, but I’d argue she was the Bronte with the sharpest observational skills.

Agnes herself is quietly devout (much like her creator) and is a very likeable protagonist. A bit like Jane Eyre, she’s a bit plain and surrounded by people who are not her equal in character, but unlike Jane she falls in love with a man who is actually a DECENT HUMAN BEING.

The Bronte romantic heroes can be problematic: I’ve made my views on Rochester fairly clear (I have since been told by many people that they disagree with me. Eh.) Heathcliff is clearly a damaged man, which is sort of understandable , considering he had a really crap childhood- although we’ll talk about that when I review Wuthering Heights. But Edward Weston is overlooked. He’s a decent man, a curate who is kind to parishoners and goes out of his way to get to know Agnes. He tracks her down after she moves away, yet does not force his presence on her. He is essentially a good, kind man- he reminds me a lot of my impression of Mr Bronte. But he is never spoken of in the same breath as his more famous counterparts, probably because nice men don’t make exciting heroes. But who would choose a bigamist who chucks his wife in the attic, or someone who decides to go on a murderous rampage of revenge over the man who rescues your dog from the evil local ratcatcher? Apparently most people. Yeah, OK.

ANYWAY. This is a short book and one that kept me company in a week in which I was full of cold and the weather was weirdly autumnal, despite being the start of summer, which felt strangely apt (I always think the Brontes are best enjoyed in the shorter days of the year for some reason.) I think everyone should have a go at reading Anne’s work, if only to appreciate the realism of her work. Although not as striking as the later Tenant of Wildfell Hall, it’s a good book if you want to understand the plight of lower middle class women in Victorian England.



  1. Wonderful review! It’s a shame that, as you say, nice men don’t make exciting heroes.

    Anne will forever be my favourite Bronte. I found Tenant of Wildfell Hall really hard going to read, but very rewarding post-read. Even though Wuthering Heights will probably always be my favourite Bronte novel, it will forever be surpassed by Anne’s work in terms of message.


  2. I loved this review! And I really love Agnes Grey; I know Weston and Agnes are hardly the traditional romantic heroes, but I think that’s why they speak to me. There’s something very subtle and beautiful about the depiction of falling in love in this book that feels realistic. One of my favorite bits is this:

    “One glance he gave, one little smile at parting. it was but for a moment, but therein I read a meaning that kindled in my heart a brighter flame of hope than had ever yet arisen.”

    The cadence of those lines are more like poetry than prose, and it really suits those quiet moments of shared understanding early on in love; when just the two of you know you share a little secret and it creates a bubble around you.

    And I like her sense of humor, in this and all that Anne wrote. She’s very serious about her beliefs, but she relieves it with recognition of the foibles and occasional idiocy of human beings. Like when Weston offers her an umbrella and she declines it, and Agnes states “I always lacked common sense when taken by surprise.” Ok, I write that out and it’s clearly not funny, but it works really well and hilariously in the book.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s